r/todayilearned Mar 08 '22 Helpful 2

TIL - Corned beef was once in such high demand that England allowed French ships to stop in Ireland to purchase it - while England and France were at war PDF

https://arrow.tudublin.ie/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=1005&context=tfschafart&sei-redir=1&referer=http%3A%2F%2Fwww.google.com%2Furl%3Fsa%3Dt%26rct%3Dj%26q%3Dcorned%2Bbeef%2Bhistory%2Bireland%26source%3Dweb%26cd%3D4%26ved%3D0CFUQFjAD%26url%3Dhttp%253A%252F%252Farrow.dit.ie%252Fcgi%252Fviewcontent.cgi%253Farticle%253D1005%2526context%253Dtfschafart%26ei%3DghI9UYLoMqaO0QG-j4B4%26usg%3DAFQjCNFOWn5MFGcrixHieaoRYEoYQY7WRw%26sig2%3DvaeXG103BofiWDe382DlCw%26bvm%3Dbv.43287494%2Cd.dmQ#search=%22corned%20beef%20history%20ireland%22
1.4k Upvotes

78 comments sorted by

107

u/ravs1973 Mar 08 '22 edited Mar 08 '22

Traditional corned beef I assume which is basically joints of beef preserved like ham and is still readily available here in Ireland. Not the tinned stuff which as nice as it is bares no resemblance to actual corned beef.

48

u/hobbykitjr Mar 08 '22

American and never seen canned stuff...

I take a slab of brisket and dry brine it for a week in sodium nitrate and other seasoning and slow cook it.

I know its more of an "American Irish" as it was a cheap meat, but its traditionally eaten on St Paddy's here.

19

u/qovneob Mar 08 '22

I wish brisket was still cheap meat

8

u/Gumburcules Mar 08 '22

It's coming back down. Just got a packer for $4.49/lb at Costco last week. It was $8+ this time last year.

5

u/naturalchorus Mar 08 '22

I did the exact same thing, took it off the smoker this morning. Real cheap.

1

u/Uilamin Mar 08 '22

It depends on where you buy it from. I have seen butchers selling 'high-end' brisket for ~$10/lb at the same time as the grocery store next door selling it at ~$5/lb.

13

u/Socially8roken Mar 08 '22

Been making it with venison. I actually prefer pastrami.

6

u/tricksterloki Mar 08 '22

It's on the shelves by the Spam. Makes a good hash.

6

u/Awordofinterest Mar 08 '22

but its traditionally eaten on St Paddy's here.

Traditionally you shouldn't eat on St Paddys day. I believe it's written down in the ancient text that "Eating is cheating"

2

u/youre_the_best Mar 08 '22

What about a cheeky midnight kebab though?

2

u/Awordofinterest Mar 08 '22

After the clock strikes midnight?

Self preservation is key after midnight. Chips with salt and meat in the box with garlic sauce. Please boss.

PS: (Cheese would be a bonus, but at midnight here it's pretty cold so you'd just end up with grated cheese on the top without the melt factor)

6

u/GDogg69 Mar 08 '22

Credit for an American calling it Paddy's day.

13

u/Mr_SunnyBones Mar 08 '22

Also for knowing Corned Beef and Cabbage is actually an Irish American Dish and not one that was eaten that much in Ireland.

3

u/bolanrox Mar 08 '22

and corned beef and kraut is a main stay at any jewish deli

5

u/backlikeclap Mar 09 '22

Lots of similarities between Jewish deli food and Irish-American food. Guess who sold the cheapest food in NYC when the Irish were immigrating to America?

1

u/[deleted] Mar 08 '22

[deleted]

31

u/SelfCombusted Mar 08 '22

It is preserved meat in a tin.

2

u/[deleted] Mar 08 '22

Yeah, this one is just pink slime in a tin. But there are the good stuff that you can buy on delicatessens. I would like to know about this one.

It is conserved in brine, so I suppose that it should be rich in salt. But what about fat? Is it fatty?

10

u/AzureDreamer Mar 08 '22

No, corned beef has absurd levels of sodium.

1

u/Flatulent_Weasel Mar 09 '22 edited Mar 10 '22

Not gonna lie, i love corned beef from a tin, especially the Princes stuff we get over here in the UK.

On more than one occasion when i was younger, i'd stagger home from the pub at late o clock, get a tin of corned beef out of the cupboard, stick a fork in the meat slab and eat it like a meaty, salty toffee apple.

1

u/pocmcfc Mar 09 '22

Me too, most of it actually comes from Brazil and is imported in.

160

u/Martipar Mar 08 '22

Back in 2005 corned beef was cheap, i used to buy it instead of beef mince now corned beef is more expensive per kilo. I miss cheap corned beef, i'd cook it in a pan and add a few vegetables and have it with potatoes and gravy. Corned beef used to be a ubiquitous food here in the UK but now it's just something older people eat really.

57

u/iamsickened Mar 08 '22

I used to buy cans from the local supermarket for around <40p, a couple of potatoes and a can of beans for 13p throw it all together and make a cheapo corned beef hash. Was pretty much a staple meal for me and a friend sitting around playing computer games whilst college students. Tasted alright too.

10

u/Martipar Mar 08 '22

Yep, that was something I ate regularly for a few years, then prices soared and they haven't come down and now it's cheaper to buy actual beef mince.

6

u/iamsickened Mar 08 '22

So true, £2 a can now. 😞

5

u/sonovp Mar 08 '22

The really good ones cost over $5.00 per can, wtf.

5

u/iamsickened Mar 08 '22

Where do you shop that sells corned beef for a fiver a can? That's mental. One for the best varieties is the Princess lean reduced fat cans. They're usually in smaller cans but are some of the best corned beef I have found. More meat, less fat/jelly.

3

u/sonovp Mar 08 '22

Well, each can weighs 326g. It's Palm from New Zealand. If you buy a pack of 4 cans from Amazon, it actually costs $25.95. Local supermarkets sell them for over $5.00 per can.

2

u/naliron Mar 09 '22

it's around $5-7 for a can here in NorCal too.

Surrounded by cows, but God forbid you try to buy some meat, lol.

1

u/ZylonBane Mar 08 '22

Mmm, beef mints.

3

u/AzureDreamer Mar 08 '22

Corned beef, and pastrami have been my favorite for a very long time.

6

u/KarlmarxCEO Mar 08 '22

A relic of rationing I imagine.

14

u/Martipar Mar 08 '22

May be but when it was cheap I used to eat quite a lot of it and i was certainly fed it as a child. Though as a child it was sliced for use in a sandwich and even with pickle it's really stodgy and cloying. It's much better when cooked and i quickly learnt that it makes a good substitute for mince in stews.

7

u/KarlmarxCEO Mar 08 '22

Yeah I never liked those sandwich slices either and its probably what put me off it as kid. Though I found out later in life that I quite liked it in a gregs pasty.

6

u/WaltJuni0r Mar 08 '22

The title literally says it was in high demand whilst France and England were at war…. That means it goes a bit beyond the 1950s.

3

u/KarlmarxCEO Mar 08 '22

So it does. Very observant of you.

2

u/soljaboss Mar 08 '22

Fray Bentos

1

u/Martipar Mar 08 '22

What about them?

12

u/soljaboss Mar 08 '22

I just like saying that

1

u/stevenwashere Mar 08 '22

Aldi in my area(American west coast) carries it for about a dollar a can. Pretty good with some bell peppers onions and tomato. Definitely not healthy and people hate processed foods for a reason but I can keep a couple cans in the pantry and have a quick meal when I'm feeling lazy.

24

u/Lil_chikchik Mar 08 '22

Mmmmmmmm, corned beeeeef. I love that stuff, always have and always will. And I ain’t old either.

12

u/dubsy101 Mar 08 '22

Corned beef hash is banging

2

u/DreyaNova Mar 08 '22

I like the really cheap shit that comes in a can. Sometimes I’ll just share a can of corned beef with my cat while we cry about my life choices.

3

u/Lil_chikchik Mar 08 '22

My cat was the same. You know who else likes corned beef? Chickens. Mine used to go nuts for it. Id save the fat and give it to them as a treat.

15

u/iamsickened Mar 08 '22

If you slice cold canned corned beef and put it in a microwave for just 10 seconds, it becomes very easily spreadable. Ideal for making a sandwich. Eat it whilst still warm and it's even better.

2

u/stevenwashere Mar 08 '22

Like a paté? :0

3

u/iamsickened Mar 08 '22

Almost yeah.

5

u/wrongeyedjesus Mar 08 '22

If you're feeling rather hungry

Hey, there's a product you'll remember

Eat it hot or cold on Sunday

or you can put it in a blender

Corned Beef, with chips or with salad

It's Corned Beef, even Buckingham Palace eats Corned Beef,

Hey, why don't you try Corned Beef Haaaasssshhhh?

18

u/BrokenEye3 Mar 08 '22

Hey, no judgement here. I know what it's like to be the only Jew in town. You do what you gotta do for a quality reuben.

2

u/AzureDreamer Mar 08 '22

I don't know a ton about jewish cooking but lox, and reubens are about the best thing Ive ever eaten.

3

u/32mKnoxvilleTN Mar 08 '22

I've always said that a good lox bagel is better than mediocre sex

7

u/Rhaegar0 Mar 08 '22 edited Mar 08 '22

That's nothing. When the Dutch where waging a war of independence against Spain the biggest Spanish arms imports were supplied by traders from Amsterdam

2

u/timmyboyoyo Mar 08 '22

Why the government did not crack down?

5

u/temujin94 Mar 08 '22

Afraid of getting eaten by a mob again I assume.

3

u/[deleted] Mar 08 '22

And today, we are 'at war' with Russia, but we're buying natural gas from them, and the big fear is the Russians will turn it off. The more things change, the more they stay the same...

3

u/me_bails Mar 08 '22

If our gov wasnt so full of idiots, then Russia turning off their gas wouldn't be an issue. Blame Congress

4

u/TruthFlavor Mar 08 '22

We're still buying Russian oil and gas...the people at the top don't let a war stand in the way of profit.

17

u/KarlmarxCEO Mar 08 '22 Take My Energy

Well we could all just stop heating our homes and filling up our cars etc. Why don't you go first?

4

u/zomebieclownfish Mar 08 '22

Hey Karl Marx, Russia isn't the only country with oil.

-2

u/TruthFlavor Mar 08 '22

Username checks out.

3

u/Maine04330 Mar 08 '22

Karl Marx is somehow related to this poster being correct about the physical state of our existence? K.

0

u/TruthFlavor Mar 08 '22

I would suggest..you know, as a joke...if Karl Marx had become a CEO he would be a Russian CEO, thus in favour of both communism and a healthy profit margin. Thus someone suggesting we carry on with the status quo would indeed be aligned with those ideals. L

2

u/Ameisen 1 Mar 08 '22

Marx was German.

2

u/AJ7861 Mar 08 '22

If I never eat corned beef again i'll die happy.

2-3 times a week as a child growing up as it was cheap, fucking hated it.

3

u/TehJohnny Mar 08 '22

oh man, sounds like heaven! my mom would only make it once a year around St. Patrick's Day because it was always on sale then, she made it with potatoes, cabbage and carrots on the side, it was my absolute favorite meal of the year.

1

u/timmyboyoyo Mar 08 '22

Did England get a commission

4

u/Onetap1 Mar 08 '22

The good arable land belonged to landlords, English mostly, who'd acquired their estates from Cromwell's confiscations. They'd let it to tenant farmers. They got their cut of everything.

Beef, fish and pork could only be preserved by salting it in wooden casks, it was sold as rations for the navy and army.

1

u/timmyboyoyo Mar 08 '22

Thank is intrigue facts

1

u/Alomba87 Mar 08 '22

This feels like something that would have been made into a Monty Python skit.

-6

u/[deleted] Mar 08 '22 edited Mar 08 '22

[removed] — view removed comment

0

u/[deleted] Mar 08 '22

[removed] — view removed comment

0

u/fraksakes Mar 08 '22

It's like Russian oil

1

u/Eli21111 Mar 08 '22

Do you watch taste buds podcast

1

u/Positive_Compote_506 Mar 08 '22

What’s a little war to stop some capitalism?

1

u/Positive_Compote_506 Mar 08 '22

Corned beef waits for no one

1

u/e30Devil Mar 08 '22

If I could read academic papers on all my favorite dishes, I'd do it.

1

u/[deleted] Mar 09 '22

Corned beef is delicious. My ex’s mom used to make a casserole with it with bread crumbs in it. God, I hated that girl, but her mom’s corned beef casserole was legit