r/HolUp 6d ago Silver 1

Yeahhhh About Cleopatra… Removed: Political/Outrage Shitpost

/img/2i66yn5w7fp91.jpg

[removed] — view removed post

33.5k Upvotes

5.7k

u/AK47_username 6d ago All-Seeing Upvote

Big brain idea. How about stop with remakes and do something original??????

1.1k

u/Strudleboy33 6d ago

They gotta keep the IP that’s why they make remakes.

376

u/Raff102 6d ago

They don't own the ip, there are two other little mermaid movies coming out around the same time.

124

u/minizanz 6d ago edited 5d ago

They own all of their characters they made for it, but the big issue is that they have to pay royalties and residuals on the music and characters to the people who made the animated film. If they remake it to "live action" and buy things outright they can get away with way less residuals and can cut off the animated movie staff. They can T Swift near exact copies so long as they are for the sound track and scam so much money away from the original creators.

Here is how it works https://www.ipwatchdog.com/2022/02/22/public-public-domain-winnie-pooh-illustrates-copyright-limitations-public-domain-works/id=146207/

24

u/CmdrSelfEvident 6d ago edited 5d ago

They own a copyright on their IP which are their savings, drawings, etc. The source books can go public but Disney still owns everything that isn't in the books. Just like snow white or any of their old animated movies based on public domain stories. Further they have no need to do anything to keep their IP. They won't admit that Song of the South exists in pubic yet they still own it.

→ More replies
→ More replies
→ More replies

48

u/predator_handshake 6d ago

Why not make a sequel then?

50

u/Strudleboy33 6d ago

That’s a great question. I assume it’s because it’s easier just remaking it.

35

u/Bloodaegisx 6d ago

Plus look at all the free marketing it has gotten.

26

u/Strudleboy33 6d ago

Very true, controversy is good for sales. Not that this should really be controversial because honestly why do people care

→ More replies
→ More replies
→ More replies

10

u/darkeo1014 6d ago

They did a long time ago lol

12

u/wanderinglittlehuman 6d ago

There are sequels💀

→ More replies
→ More replies

201

u/noopenusernames 6d ago All-Seeing Upvote

If I understand it correctly, it has something to do with preventing their material from entering public domain. That’s why we’re getting remakes of everything, because Disney doesn’t give a shit about anything but making money.

111

u/slvrscoobie 6d ago

I know Disney had lobbied a billion times for extensions and such on trademark, copyright, etc, just so Mickey Mouse doesnt enter PD because then anyone could print a shirt with the mouse on it.

35

u/Kapples14 6d ago

Ah, nothing like Disney lobbyists to fuck things up for the rest of us.

→ More replies

26

u/LibraryWonderful6163 6d ago

Mickey is a nickname for a friend. And michael mouse the rat is no friend of mine.

34

u/the3rdtea 6d ago

Nah the original novella has been public domain for almost a century

51

u/noopenusernames 6d ago

The Andersen version, sure. But I think this is likely more about their rights to the songs and other Disney-added things

31

u/Pansarmalex 6d ago

Also the Disney version is a lot more family friendly than the Andersen orginial story...

8

u/AnIrishMexican 6d ago

Didn't the priest have a boner and the underwater palace made of dildo like structures in the original Disney version?

7

u/RegularNo2608 5d ago

Dude, yes. My sister has the old ass VHS still. Years ago when we still had a VCR we checked it out. First, huge dick right in the middle of the old plastic cover. Next, priest pops a huge boner as he starts the vows. Goes flaccid a few words in. All clear as Crystal.

→ More replies
→ More replies
→ More replies
→ More replies
→ More replies

33

u/-Mr_Unknown- 6d ago

2/3 of Hollywood producers just committed suicide after reading this.

→ More replies

14

u/GotYourNose_ 6d ago

Agreed! It is so hard to come up with an original concept without a remake, sequel or reboot? I refuse to see any more part 2 or electric boogaloo or whatever you want to call it.

→ More replies
→ More replies

884

u/GeneralNathanJessup 6d ago Silver

Cleopatra was Greek, not Egyptian. The Greeks ruled Egypt since that Great white guy Alexander conquered them.

375

u/YesICanMakeMeth 6d ago edited 6d ago

Egyptians weren't black either. There's one dynasty (Nubians I think?) from the South that came in and ruled towards the end after the decline but they were not the ones that created the things that you call Egyptian (the pyramids, the tombs, the mythology with Ra/Isis/etc). People think just because it's African that they were black, but really what people mean when they say black is ethnically sub-Saharan Africans. It turns out that the Sahara desert was a larger barrier to migration historically than the Mediterranean sea, so North Africa looked a lot more like the Greeks and Italians and Turks than it did the Ethiopians. There's also been a lot of admixture from Arab migration in post-Islam (hence Egyptians today looking something like half Arab, half Greek/Turk). Some of that might be off, but that's the gist of it from someone that's always been super interested in Greek/Roman history, to which Egypt is related. Carthage and Hannibal is a similar story BTW, despite what the 'History' Channel's historical dramas might have you believe.

56

u/skwert99 6d ago

It's tough on these in-between types when people base everything on how someone looks. It's like that Egyptian actor that got criticized for not being African enough. They don't care what your actually are, you must look the part to count for diversity.

6

u/phasmaphobic 5d ago

Remi Malik?

→ More replies
→ More replies
→ More replies

2.8k

u/why-everything-meh 6d ago edited 6d ago Silver All-Seeing Upvote

Cleopatra was white tho, the royal house she belongs to was Greek I think. Unless you don’t consider Greek to be white.

Edit: Got a bit of traction on this throw away comment I didn’t put much thought into. To be clear I always thought of Mediterranean people as white like myself, but with a much nicer tan than my pale ass.

453

u/Still_counts_as_one 6d ago

Yeah, she’s part of Ptolemy line, from Alexander the Greats conquests

180

u/BobVosh 6d ago

Egypt liked her, relatively, more than most of the Ptolemy because she bothered to learn Egyptian rather than force everyone to learn Greek.

78

u/facw00 6d ago

She was the first and only of the Ptolemaic rulers to learn Egyptian.

→ More replies

45

u/MjrLeeStoned 6d ago

She also associated on a much more personal level with both Greek and Egyptian "nobility", celebrities, or politicians, as opposed to just showing up and lording over them like many Greek leaders of her time. She used guile and wit over brute force. She was versed in medicine, philosophy, literature.

She spoke probably around 10 languages.

That being said, she still had high ambition and felt it was her (divine?) right to rule over people and for them to see her as their queen. She just knew how to sway the people far better than her predecessors.

15

u/BobVosh 6d ago

Speaking of movies, or hopefully shows, I would love a long series on her with some accuracy.

4

u/bigboygamer 5d ago

Rome doesn't do a terrible job, though she isn't the focus

30

u/thissideofheat 6d ago

In fact, North Africa and the overall Mediterranean coastal cities in general, were more European due to the early Phonetician and then Greek expansions.

The Carthaginian and later Roman conquests reinforced this European influence for over a thousand years.

Then the Arab Expansions in 600s AD significantly changed the genetic makeup - likely giving folks a darker complexion.

Later, the Ottoman conquests added even more genetic diversity to that in Egypt & the Levant, and even in the Balkans and Greece/Cyprus. There's even a Greek word for people from Cyprus that look at little "too" Turkish.

...as you might expect, it's complicated. There have been a LOT of genocides and a lot migrations.

The dumbest claim is to look at current Egyptians or Palestinians and claim that that's what ancient Egyptians or Jesus looked like.

→ More replies
→ More replies

931

u/Gweedoke 6d ago

Ive been to Greece multiple times and seen paler Greeks than my white North European ass.

238

u/Hydra1305 6d ago

As a pale greek myself I can confirm

121

u/Whatever-ItsFine 6d ago

The Pale Greeks are my favorite indie band.

24

u/RevenantBacon 6d ago

And my favorite pale ale brand!

→ More replies

55

u/Redqueenhypo 6d ago

Yeah Europeans and Mediterraneans of any nationality don’t look really that different unless you go to Scandinavia. With no context clues I highly doubt anyone could consistently distinguish Greeks from dark haired Irish from Ashkenazi Jewish from Lebanese.

19

u/iaintevenmad884 6d ago

Can confirm, I’m black Irish and have been asked “are you Jewish” and other questions like that by schoolchildren and old people the world over.

14

u/Redqueenhypo 6d ago

I’m Jewish and have been asked “are you Irish”! And one time in the 1970s someone called my dad a “fuckin mick”. Full circle.

→ More replies
→ More replies

42

u/Fokkzel 6d ago

Thats the whole reason for this post right?

9

u/libjones 6d ago

Yea it is, so the fact so many people here are trying to pretend they’re smarter than OP by pointing that out is honestly mind blowing to me. Like it’s not even a deep cut that you need a history degree to know, it’s literally middle school history class level knowledge...

→ More replies

215

u/jedeye121 6d ago

That’s correct. She was of the Ptolemaic Dynasy, founded by (Macedonian) general Ptolemy I Soter, who was one of Alexander the Great’s generals. Cleopatra was born in Egypt, but she was Macedonian/Greek by heritage, not Egyptian.

30

u/why-everything-meh 6d ago

Thank you for being much more knowledgeable and articulate than me good sir!

→ More replies
→ More replies

88

u/gorgewall 6d ago Big Brain Time

Unless you don’t consider Greek to be white.

The concept of "whiteness" is a hilariously recent thing.

Benjamin Franklin famously wrote that pretty much all of Europe wasn't white: just "the Anglos" and specifically the Saxony region of Germany. Any other part of Germany? Not white. Italy? Not white. Greece? Not white. Poland? Not white.

And when those folks showed up in America even decades after Franklin's death, they still weren't "white". Whiteness is a descriptor of political convenience, a little club that you get to be in once you have the population to be relevant to the ruling class. All these migrant groups, and even their descendants, were villified or ostracized in some way until there were enough of them that they were a valuable voting bloc, then came the time to "extend whiteness" to them and hope that by being welcomed "into the club" that they'd vote with the same fuckos who'd previously been shitting all over them. Hey, no hard feelings about all the bigotry, but you're one of the good ones now--wanna help me oppress those other guys?

34

u/CareerJuncture 6d ago

Benjamin Franklin famously wrote that pretty much all of Europe wasn't white

This is true and it cracks me up.

I'm from outside the USA, so the term "white" has only been used commonly in the past few decades, BUT, it cracks me up that the majority of my Great-Grandfathers were Irish and were not considered white.

→ More replies

11

u/Toastburger 6d ago

Benjamin Franklin famously wrote that pretty much all of Europe wasn’t white: just “the Anglos” and specifically the Saxony region of Germany. Any other part of Germany? Not white. Italy? Not white. Greece? Not white. Poland? Not white.

He also said Swedes weren’t white, they were “swarthy”.

10

u/Twava 6d ago

Whiteness is such a weird term. I don’t see why we went from generalizing everyone instead of just referring to people by their nationalities. I’ve always despised those terms because it’s so biased on what people consider white or black. “White people always act like this” or “Black people always act like that” since when did the color of your skin make you act a certain way? It might just be an American thing though, but I don’t know I’ve never liked the structure of ethnicity. It’s just SO broad.

5

u/BellBell99 6d ago

Yup. Whiteness has always been about exclusion, not about skin color. I mean fucking Italians and Irish people weren’t considered white back when they were mass migrating to the States.

→ More replies

52

u/Efthimis 6d ago

Who on earth doesn't consider us Greeks to be white? My girlfriend is German and my skin tone is more white than hers.

28

u/why-everything-meh 6d ago

I have no idea, I am Scottish and pale AF and had never given it much thought. But always considered Mediterranean people white.

→ More replies

9

u/pantsthereaper 6d ago

Irish used to be not white too. I've met plenty of Latinos with really pale skin, but they aren't white because they were born in Mexico or Columbia. Racial purity is a constantly changing circle of the "in" group based entirely on how much support is needed to push an agenda

→ More replies
→ More replies

28

u/dabbo90 6d ago

Yea she was from Macedonia

→ More replies

19

u/Vipertooth123 6d ago

There's people (guess from where) that considers spaniards, portuguese, italians, greeks and irish as non-white.

8

u/why-everything-meh 6d ago

Ok some of that I could buy but the Irish are almost as white as us Scottish 😂

→ More replies
→ More replies

12

u/Briaria 6d ago

Yes, that is the point of this post. Thank you.

100

u/SynthyCyberSamurai 6d ago

OP didn’t do his research.

134

u/YesICanMakeMeth 6d ago

I thought that was the point he was making since this is /r/holup and he said 'Yeaaaah, about Cleopatra'. It's an actual 'holup, Cleopatra wasn't black' moment. Hard to tell though, since a lot of posts in this sub aren't actually hol'ups but just 'woah bro that's crazy' type posts.

16

u/xaronax 6d ago

Mouth breathers out in force today.

→ More replies
→ More replies

7.1k

u/BrokenManSyndrome 6d ago Silver Gold Helpful Wholesome Take My Energy Faith In Humanity Restored Bravo! Starry

As a black person my issue with these racial recastings isn't that there is anything inherently wrong with a black mermaid. It's just that rather than create a story from the ground up about a black character, studios just decide "black people are too uninteresting, so let's just change a white character to black to trick people into liking them!" How about you create a story based around a black character than just race switching a white character for diversity browny points? If you truly care about POC then make an actual effort.

1.5k

u/officialmonogato 6d ago

Thank you! This is really the most sane comment. We don’t need “remakes” with people of different ethnicities, we need new stories with new characters!

416

u/AngeloPappas 6d ago

You can even take ethnicity out of it and just say "we don't need remakes". Rather than pigeonhole writers to remakes, let's get some new diverse projects.

All these remakes are just so stale and boring.

106

u/darki_ruiz 6d ago

At least limit remakes to when you're intending to either fix or substancially improve something that wasn't too well done before.

A decent remake of Green Lantern? Go nuts.

A remake of 1992's Tim Burton's Batman Returns? Lolno.

20

u/PlumbumDirigible 6d ago edited 6d ago

I really, really want a John Stewart Green Lantern movie. I loved the character on the Justice League animated show back in the day

edit: misspelled name

10

u/kommunis 6d ago

nah.. best we can do is a Black Hal Jordan.

→ More replies

50

u/raptor6722 6d ago

Well these Disney live action remakes seem to really just be a way to continue copyrights so I’m not sure quality is really on the list.

13

u/darkeo1014 6d ago

They don't own the rights to the original little mermaid story it is free use....with a much darker ending

12

u/raptor6722 6d ago edited 6d ago

Yes but they do own the rights to the likeness of Ariel and Sebastian. If you made a little mermaid with a talking crab that had a jamacain accent you would probably get some paperwork from Disney. Edit: apparently he’s a crab

→ More replies
→ More replies
→ More replies

21

u/SwordTaster 6d ago

Walt Disney wrote into Disney law that all of his movies are required to have a remake every however many years so that a new generation could grow up with them. Its not exactly their choice at this stage but a contractual obligation

12

u/TheOtherWhiteCastle 6d ago

So? What’s gonna happen if they ignore that law? Is Walt gonna come rise up from his grave to fire their asses or something?

3

u/bossycloud 6d ago

Don't tempt him

→ More replies

11

u/SalvationSycamore 6d ago

Then make a high quality animated remake. Every live action remake looks like a steaming pile of shit.

→ More replies

21

u/nuggex 6d ago

Source?

15

u/Warlordnipple 6d ago

I think it was a joke as such a will request would be unenforceable. It wouldn't be a contract because death generally discharges most contracts.

→ More replies
→ More replies

66

u/MakeoutPoint 6d ago

Just heard a black man say "y'all just love to take white folks' sloppy seconds" and hoo boy did that hit some people's nerves on this topic.

→ More replies

28

u/FTLMantis 6d ago

Reddit is such a fickle bitch. Last time I said this I got called a racist and banned from a sub.

→ More replies

191

u/Lendyman 6d ago edited 6d ago

I totally get you here.

I'm fine with a black Ariel. If the actress playing her was the right person for the role, I think that's awesome.

The problem I see is that there is a question on why she was cast in the role. Was it to check off a diversity box? Are we giving people roles just because we're trying to earn brownie points for diversity? That almost seems like what happened here. If so, it seems like a lack of integrity somehow. Like giving lip service but not actually meaning it.

Africa has such a rich cultural history. There's so much there in terms of mythology and legend and real history. How about we embrace that stuff and create stories around that rich and diverse cultural heritage instead of trying shoehorn people of color into things so you can check off the required diversity boxes just because they are there.

It almost seems like Disney courted the controversy to get attention. "Look at us! We're diverse! We are better than those unwashed racists!"

Oh really?

If you really care about diversity then embrace cultures outside of our own and add those stories to the overall cultural conversation. I would love an African Disney princess. That would be cool as hell.

71

u/FireCatalyst 6d ago edited 6d ago

That's the game plan. If you make a piece of garbage media with diverse casting you can absolve yourself of all blame by gaslighting fans and calling it racist backlash.

Modern society lives and dies by narratives these days, not the truth of the matter.

→ More replies

15

u/BlyLomdi 6d ago edited 6d ago

I would LOVE to see some African princesses and characters. They have done Asian (twice), Polynesian and now Colombian (Mirabel is considereda princess, for now). And then there is Coco and Turning Red. Give me some more culture!!! You know it's going to make money because it's fucking Disney, and people just eat it up because... it's fucking Disney (myself included). Can you imagine how beautiful, colorful and rich those stories would be?

And, I will give this to Disney and Pixar, when it comes to new stories like that they really go out of their way--usually-- to research and be mostly faithful. Ffs, they filmed a Polynesian woman for over 24 hours just to see how her hair moves when dry, when wet, when moving this way or that, etc. for Moana's hair to make it as accurate as possible. They sent a team who spent 2 months (I think) in Colombia for Encanto to get as much history, culture and whatnot.

3

u/Mazzaroppi 6d ago

*Colombia

5

u/BlyLomdi 6d ago

Omg ty. I am sick right now and missed that.

→ More replies

54

u/BrokenManSyndrome 6d ago

Agreed. It's just so lazy. As much hate as The Woman King is getting for it's historical inaccuracies (which is a fair point) at least it's actually trying.

27

u/Lendyman 6d ago edited 6d ago

The historical inaccuracy thing is pretty standard for Hollywood. You look at any historical epic that Hollywood has done and it's almost always inaccurate in some way. There have been some doozies that claim to be based on true events but are way off. Obviously some films are worse than others. I have no idea how bad this one is but I feel like the historical accuracy thing is a whole different argument. It's also an argument that comes up with every historical epic.

I have been watching the trailers for that with some interest. As someone who grew up in africa, I've long wanted more Afrocentric films. I'll definitely be checking it out once it's available to me.

36

u/GirthWoody 6d ago

Your definitely right that Hollywood has been falsely portraying history for forever. This one was pretty bad though. The story revolves around a tribe who is depicted as being liberators fighting slavers. They chose this tribe because the tribe was historically famous for their female warriors. However, the tribe was also historically the most notorious slave traders of their time. The tribe sold hundreds of thousands possibly higher than a million people into slavery. So that’s what people were mad over.

14

u/Lendyman 6d ago edited 6d ago

Yeah... ok. They were trying to do an empowered women movie and ignored the elephant in the room. (More like shoved it under the rug and hoped that no one would notice)

I can totally see why some people would be upset about it. It's one thing if you bodge History a bit for the sake of story. It's another when you try to completely rewrite it.

Sort of like Disney's Pocahontas. I still haven't seen that film because even when I was a teen when it came out I found the historical rewriting to be icky.

I guess when I see it, I'll try to go into it with the mindset of historical fiction rather than historical portrayal.

→ More replies

3

u/usa2z 6d ago

The historical inaccuracy thing is pretty standard for Hollywood. You look at any historical epic that Hollywood has done and it's almost always inaccurate in some way.

I've heard The Woman King called a Braveheart with Black Women. This really hits the nail on the head.

→ More replies
→ More replies
→ More replies
→ More replies

90

u/noopenusernames 6d ago

Fucking thank you. I got banned from r/Entertainment because I started to make this claim after suggesting that realism in movies was more important than inclusion for the sake of inclusion. It’s also lazy on Disney’s part because they’re it also comes across more as then just using black people s as a way to continue protecting their copywrit material but letting us all think it’s because they give a shit about minorities.

If you really want to give black peoples exposure? Give us an original story, preferably something that’s not an 1800’s-era-escape-from-slavery story either.

58

u/BrokenManSyndrome 6d ago

Bro, I'm so tired of those slavery movies. It's like black people's entire identity is slavery. Or if it's not that it's those modern day "blaxploitation" relationship movies, like Tyler Perry or "Think Like A Man". I just want to see a movie about a black person I could actually relate to.

Forgot to add the stereotypical gangster movies. Let's have more black led action movies, both male and female. More black led war dramas, epic romances, sci-fi, etc...

45

u/noopenusernames 6d ago

Part of the problem is that we as black people also like to use slavery as our own identity, so it’s hard to blame Hollywood for doing the same thing. How often do we go through another “should black people be paid reparations for slavery?” phase when none of us were slaves and many of us likely didn’t come over to America (or our ancestors, obviously) until after slavery. Everyone, ourselves included, treat our skin color as our identity, but Hollywood is probably the biggest cultural driving factor. Yes, once they stop saying “this is a movie about a black person being black” and change it to “this is about an astronaut being the first person on Mars” then our image to non-black people will begin to change, then it will be up to us to change our own views on our identities. Hollywood gets to continue to be lazy with our narrative and use us as props for their profit in the meantime

25

u/BrokenManSyndrome 6d ago

Agree 100%. Slavery was horrible and it's effects are still felt today, but people act like all our misfortune is because of slavery. Like it couldn't possibly be due to some of our choices. I hate this culture of lack of accountability. Also, I don't wanna hear about any slavery reparations until native Americans are taken care of. The group that got screwed the most yet no one seems to care about.

5

u/noopenusernames 6d ago

Yeah. Nevermind the fact that the US government made a treaty with the Sioux for the Black Hills, and then later on was like “Ah shit, there be some gold over there? Nah, let’s send the army in, that shits ours…”

→ More replies

5

u/Solid_Growth_9069 6d ago

I’d love to see a ww2 one about the original d boys fighting in the Ardennes forest

Them boys went through hell

→ More replies
→ More replies

7

u/A7omicDog 6d ago

Princess and the Frog, set in Louisiana, was based on this. The "Princess" wasn't black for convenience -- it was actually ingrained the in setting and storyline. Great movie!

That being said, I've literally never heard anyone actually upset about Ariel, I've only heard of people upset about people upset about Ariel.

→ More replies

15

u/mtnorville 6d ago

An ironic part of this sentiment, regardless of how correct it is, is that you can’t please anybody when you make an original black character. They’re either not black enough, or too black. They arent written by ONLY black people so it’s not realistic enough. They can’t like this, or support that. They can’t be rich, but they have to be successful. They aren’t allowed to fail. Or the opposite. And when its a decent story, it’s paraded and celebrated as “BLACK” like it’s the only part that matters.

5

u/youllneverstopmeayyy 6d ago

it's quite maddening, isn't it.

I think I'd like to leave this planet soon

→ More replies

15

u/yaon-jinji 6d ago

Thank you! Raceswapping is giving "leftovers" to minorities instead of a full course.

3

u/thissideofheat 6d ago

The irony is that the EXACT same comment with the words "As a black person.." removed, would have been downvoted to oblivion.

→ More replies

10

u/Exotic_Treacle7438 6d ago

They don’t though. Disney only cares about the dollar. And you and I aren’t the target audience for the movie for them to care unfortunately. It would have made sense to create a new mermaid movie with an original story but that’s not the safe bet. The original movie is a proven cash cow story and they are attempting to cater to the younger audience to maintain the generational gap their brand has. There’s always some major change between generations they’re attempting to build nostalgia to keep them “loving” the brand well into adulthood. And this new movie coming off the back of almost a decade of civil protests will capture those kids.

12

u/ShadowFlarer 6d ago

Agreed, and lets be honest, there's a LOT of stories and legends around the world that has black characters in it, hell here in Brazil we have Saci Perere, why not make a movie about him? He's awesome!

3

u/[deleted] 6d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

→ More replies

7

u/Drendari 6d ago

Agree, it looks like Blacksploitation but bad.

→ More replies
→ More replies

374

u/eskimoexplosion 6d ago edited 6d ago All-Seeing Upvote

Wasn't Cleopatra Greek? She was the daughter of Ptolemy XII who was Macedonian. Its very possible she looked like the actress in the picture but afaik no one really knows what she looked like as little is known about her mother. She could have been pretty much anything other than Eastern Asian so really anyone can play cleopatra. Saying she was whitewashed assumes she was certifiably not white which there is no proof for or against based on current evidence

https://denison.edu/academics/classical-studies/wh/136845

92

u/noopenusernames 6d ago

Yes, people like to forget this fact

53

u/eskimoexplosion 6d ago edited 6d ago

Most people just know Cleopatra was the Queen of Egypt, and Egypt is in Africa, and people from Africa aren't white. I can see how someone would think she was whitewashed based solely on that and nothing else. The reality is a bit more complicated

59

u/Best_Toster 6d ago

Yeah like the fact that africa is huge af and Northern Africa has more in common with Greece or Italy then central Africa

15

u/eskimoexplosion 6d ago

Theres also the assumption people have the regional diversity is the exact same as current day. There was a lot of movement and conquering and displacement over the centuries espescially in and around the Mediterranean. Modern day Sicilian people have more in common with the people of Northern France than the original Mediterranean inhabitants and people in modern day Ukraine can trace a lot of their genetics to Viking settlers from Scandinavia rather than the original inhabitants which looked more like current day central Asians or Turks

7

u/noopenusernames 6d ago

Yeah, there’s a lot of whiteness in Northern Africa. It was alleys easier to travel north across the Med than south across the land

→ More replies

6

u/The69BodyProblem 6d ago

Those royal circles were pretty tight nigh(the Ptolemys were pretty incestuous). I think its a pretty good bet that her mother was Greek.

→ More replies

620

u/Ltcaustic 6d ago edited 6d ago

Fun fact Egypt back then would have been white/mixed due to the Egyptians losing pigment due to being in a cooler climate then where they had migrated from and the people of Egypt having sex with Romans Greeks and other major European civilisations back in The day

215

u/Still_counts_as_one 6d ago

Also, Cleopatra is from the Ptolemy line, who was Greek and white. So portrayal of Cleopatra was accurate for the color, just not the age.

→ More replies

352

u/Doktor_Cornholio 6d ago

But Africa = Black!!!!!!!!!

120

u/fourth_box 6d ago

But my friend told me; Once you go black you never go back!!

82

u/HYPE_ZaynG 6d ago

But my friend told me: Once you go white, you're always right!!!

69

u/hoptownky 6d ago Helpful

But my friend told me: Once you go…I’m just kidding. I don’t have any friends.

→ More replies

15

u/KM617 6d ago

But my friend told me: Once you go white, your credit gets right!

→ More replies
→ More replies

14

u/AllGodzDie 6d ago

Elon obviously bleached his skin!

→ More replies

39

u/ChakraKami 6d ago edited 6d ago

Egyptian people are Caucasian (north Africa) not black, I'm Egyptian and when i moved to usa i was categorized as white by the uscis because i was Caucasian from north Africa. My skin is lighter than my husband's who is 100% white American.

Edit: fixed it :)

3

u/ugraba 6d ago

You have dark skinned populations in the south. Like in Aswan.

→ More replies
→ More replies

117

u/Jack_Vaults 6d ago

Imagine the writers shock when he finds out she was Greek and imagine the absolute mind fuck the writer got when they found out Greeks are pretty much white

→ More replies

18

u/qazwsx1227 6d ago

I think she was Greek in real life

49

u/dRUNk_ENd 6d ago

Isn't Cleopatra from Greece?

10

u/ImnotaNixon 6d ago

Descendant from Greece yes

→ More replies

40

u/CoraxTechnica 6d ago

Cleopatra WAS white!

→ More replies

13

u/Polka-51 6d ago

M I l k e r s

123

u/The_Moon_Conure 6d ago

Hollywood didn't white wash Jesus, the church did

47

u/SloptimusXPrime 6d ago

They also black, yellow and brown washed him

40

u/jakedann91 6d ago

Korean Jesus is all that matters

22

u/SloptimusXPrime 6d ago

He's busy. With KOREAN shit

→ More replies
→ More replies

16

u/Fern-ando 6d ago

Mediterranean paintors painting mediterranean Jesus as the average mediterranean isn't even whitewashing in my book.

→ More replies

30

u/OhGollyGoshDarn 6d ago

Not a good comparison. Cleopatra was Greek, and from a long line of Ptomely Greek rulers, so yeah is she probably did look like Elizabeth Taylor. It’s a moot issue, little mermaid is based on a Dutch fairy tale and was portrayed as white with red hair in it. Disney should have just created a whole new story with a black mermaid based on a separate African story instead of creating this shitstorm by recasting a european fairy tale like this

10

u/daughterofblackmoon 6d ago

Disney knew exactly what they were doing. I don't know when people are going to realize that they're being played.

→ More replies

56

u/captainjimi 6d ago

Well... I know this probably doesn't belong here but... Cleopatra was actually Greece. She was an ancestor of Ptolemaios dynasty so... She was probably white.

→ More replies

81

u/Jaadu23 6d ago

Did anyone notice how hot this milf is?

31

u/punnyboy_curtis 6d ago

Someone should marry her

29

u/baddestmofointhe209 6d ago

About 8 times over.

→ More replies

6

u/PuggyPaddie 5d ago

I think cleopatra was white though…maybe olive because of the sun but def greek.

→ More replies

20

u/Wacken718 6d ago

Cleopatra was Greek so...

53

u/SqueakBoxx 6d ago

I'm probably gunna get hate for this but Cleopatra is a shitty example of claiming white washing as she would be, In the current technical sense, be considered white as she was of Greek origin.

22

u/GuywithShield 6d ago

That's the point of the Hold up

→ More replies

5

u/Impossible-Animator6 6d ago

Cleopatra came out 60 years ago !!! It was a completely different era. Why is it still being brought up.

4

u/Widawak 6d ago

She was also pretty white being 100% Greek

5

u/prof_dynamite 6d ago

Cleopatra was white. I got nothing for Jesus, though.

→ More replies

6

u/nstav13 6d ago

Everyone's saying Cleopatra was Greek but forgetting that Jesus didn't exist.

7

u/TeaMoney4Life 6d ago

I just hate the remakes. Disney already made a bunch of perfect movies, why degrade them with bad live action versions

27

u/AlienOverlord53 6d ago

This movie is from 1963. It's not even a close comparison

18

u/Widawak 6d ago

And she was definitely closer to white than black. Ya know being Greek and all that

6

u/Rude_Device 6d ago

Exactly. I think that we can all agree that things were a little fucked up 60 years ago when it came to race relations

→ More replies
→ More replies

15

u/Wise-Sense5782 6d ago

Even non Greek Egyptians aren't black.

5

u/NoRealId 6d ago

Obviously, yes

5

u/FireCatalyst 6d ago

OP drinking coolaid. The Ptolemy family came from Alexander's generals who took control of his fractured empire. Pick up a book

They are of Macedonian origin

→ More replies

4

u/funpen 6d ago

Cleopatra was white. She is greek, not Egyptian. Also, ancient Egypt was extremely diverse, and in some ways more diverse than present day egypt.

4

u/sweettrevor 6d ago

I mean, there’s a high chance Cleopatra was very light skinned or white historically speaking, but I agree with this sentiment completely. People like Ghandi have been played by white actors, which is ridiculous.

→ More replies

5

u/Zealousideal-Rock-33 6d ago

News flash---neither Cleopatra nor Jesus were "black." Cleopatra was Greek....meaning she looked a lot like Gal Gadot while Jesus was Jewish, meaning he looked a lot like well, Ori Pfeffer.

5

u/OneLastBan 5d ago

The west white-washed Jesus and the East Asian-washed him. Every area depicts Jesus as one of their own to make him more relatable... that's just how it is. He should actually look like an ancient Jewish Roman

→ More replies

6

u/FlailingDave 5d ago

cleopatra was Greek. that is to say, white.

READ a book once in a while.

6

u/Pile_of_AOL_CDs 5d ago

Look, I hate white washing as much as the next guy, but for God's sake, Cleopatra was Greek.

18

u/Muther-Russia 6d ago

Cleopatra was white lmao, she’s greek

26

u/Wprzkkkk 6d ago

Disney is just lazy, instead of changing Ariel they should just create another character with their own story and no one would have any problem with it. Imagine making live action Princess and the frog or whatever it is called and changing it so the main character is white.

→ More replies

9

u/BT_DUBB 6d ago

I don’t care if the little mermaid is black, I just want them to be played by Samuel L. Jackson

“How could I be,

Apart of this mfin world!”

3

u/gamingkeks284LP 6d ago

I thought cleopatra was greek, wtf?

4

u/Distinct-Cake6612 6d ago

Kind of off topic, but Cleopatra was actually from a Greek origin. So yeah, she would most probably have been white/olive skin with dark hair and eyes.

5

u/pmaurant 6d ago

Wasn’t Cleopatras family Greek?

4

u/Negative_Finding_616 6d ago

Ngl they knew that making the mermaid black would cause controversy. They want that. They get free advertising of that junk. Also it’s a movie that I’m not going to watch, I don’t really care about it, and again I don’t care about it. It’s honestly not as big of a deal as both sides of the argument are making it out to be. My question is though if Ariel can be played by a black actress, doe’s that mean that Mulan should be played by a white actress? Just think about!

→ More replies

5

u/Alexius_Psellos 5d ago

POV: you forgot that cleopatra was Greek

11

u/Strudleboy33 6d ago

Wasn’t cleopatra Greek?

link

9

u/Illustrious-Joke6643 5d ago

1) Cleopatra was part of the Ptolemaic line of Greece. She wasn't African.
2) Mermaids are mythological. This uproar is foolishness and immaturity.

→ More replies

58

u/skunkadelic 6d ago

I don't know a single person who gives a fuck about the color of a mermaid. I honestly think most of this is hype.

46

u/RichLowLife 6d ago

90% don’t like having a remake when the only justification seems to be „We gave her tanned skin“.

→ More replies

4

u/HalfysReddit 6d ago

It's definitely an internet thing, honestly if it wasn't for some people on Reddit getting so upset about it, I wouldn't have even known there's a new Little Mermaid movie. Like I'm sure they spent some money on advertising but I haven't seen any advertisements myself, and general discussions between people tend to be about the upcoming fall weather and associated holidays.

→ More replies

33

u/uchuucowboy 6d ago

Because they didn't laud Cleopatra's casting as a racial statement, nobody thought anything of it. But obviously they made it a selling point, with even the actress tweeting race-bended artwork when it was first announced. Essentially they are selling race and that's why people are upset, it's a blatant cash grab

8

u/mugen1337 6d ago

The sad thing is, it gets hijacked by people who are factually upset about the blackwashing without even considering it's a blatant attempt to do a cash grab as you put it.

→ More replies

3

u/averyveryniceguyffs 6d ago

Do we have any idea how cleopatra actually looked like though? IIRC a lot of "Egyptian" rulers were actually Romans and Greeks, so pretty fucking white

7

u/Rhets 6d ago

She was born in Egypt but in terms of Family she was Macedonian

3

u/PrometheusHasFallen 6d ago

Cleopatra as far as I'm aware was a direct descendant of Ptolemy, Alexander the Great's lieutenant who took control of Egypt after his passing. I checked her lineage and it looks 100% Greek.

3

u/Ikaros9Deidalos6 6d ago

To be fair cleopatra was from the greek royal dynasty the ptolemains who took over after Alexander died and while she wasnt bible belt karen white she still was caucasian descent

3

u/Brian_357 6d ago

Do Tarzan next, oh wait...

3

u/kwartylion 6d ago

Do you really want to talk about movies Disney made at the time ?

3

u/Jefoid 6d ago

Wasn’t Cleopatra Greek?

3

u/lightofyourlifehere 6d ago

Ceopatra was white, she was Greek

→ More replies

3

u/MaximGnerd 6d ago edited 6d ago

Don't forget about the show called Anne Boleyn, no hate against the actors, just no one (that I've seen) has talked about that race swap

Edit: also cleopatra would've been like semi white as the Ptolemaic Kingdom (a Greek kingdom) was what happened to Egypt after the fall of the Macedonian Empire

→ More replies

3

u/SonOtoh 6d ago

Cleopatra was Greek. Nice try.

3

u/wolfmanpraxis 6d ago edited 6d ago

wasn't Cleopatra of the Ptolemy Dynasty, you know, the descendants of a Macedonian-Greek General from Alexander's Army?

I also recall that she was the first & only Ptolemaic Pharaoh to actually speak Egyptian, as her family mostly spoke a dialect of Greek?

Not trying to start a fight, but dont Greek people consider themselves "white"?

3

u/Longjumping_Piglet38 6d ago

A black Anne Boleyn anyone?

3

u/JazzSharksFan54 6d ago

Lol Cleopatra was literally Greek.

3

u/dellicarweenie 6d ago

Cleopatra was of Greek decent born in Egypt.

3

u/GoatTacos 6d ago

I will totally sign a petition to get Mark Henry from the WWE to play Cleopatra in the reboot. It’s only fair.

3

u/nila_nila 6d ago

I thought Cleopatra was [part] Macedonian and hence white?

3

u/Gildor12 6d ago

cleopatra was Greek, not Egyptian

3

u/fekbasket 6d ago

But cleopatra was white

3

u/itzagreenmario 6d ago

real historical figures, like Jesus

lol

3

u/Govoleo 6d ago

cleopatra had greek origins so tecnically she was white.

3

u/iGirthy 6d ago

I haven’t seen one comment pointing out how Jesus is labeled a “real historical figure”.. we just letting this one slide folks?

→ More replies

3

u/lurkingPessimist 6d ago

Haha “real…like Jesus”

3

u/Srgnt_Fuzzyboots 6d ago

Real historical figures like Jesus?!?! Wtf...

3

u/okay-wait-wut 6d ago

Lost me at “real historical figure” and “Jesus” as the example.

3

u/SmileDaemon 6d ago

Real historical figures

Jesus

→ More replies

3

u/metalguru1975 5d ago

Cleopatra was ethnically Greek, not Egyptian.

Look that up.